Back in 2001 I was racing shifty-squishy bikes and hell bent on racing 12’s and 24’s till my legs fell off. I invested in two identical pairs of Shimano M-320’s so I could have a spare pair of freshies if I needed them. Although they were yellow, purple, silver, blue, black, and yelllow-orange (ish) they quickly unseated the Sidi Dominator as my favorite shoe.

The M-320’s had rubber lugs unlike their high end Sidi counterparts which had silly hard plastic lugs that were slippery as shit when walking in the Pisgah. The fit was spot-on, and I just love having clicky buckle shoes. There was a downside:

Toe spike holes. Toe spikes are as worthless as Lehman Brothers stock. The downside is that the little metal things that replaced them were more slippery than polytetrafluoroethene. I removed them entirely, but that only exposed to front of the shoe to premature wear (as evidenced in the picture). These were the best shoes ever, but time has not been their best friend, and they have only been recently brought back outta retirement temporarily (like Lance) to fill the shoe shoes of the aging Tinker Stinkers.
When the M-320’s were no longer the bees knees I had to replace them. I committed to the NUE series back in 2006, and new shoes were on order. I found a pair of M-181’s on sale, and since I loved my other poorly named Shimano shoes (I mean seriously, are these things Terminators or shoes?) I scooped up a pair.

The non-carpet fiber soles were adorned with rubber lugs, the color scheme a little less “queer eye for the straight guy’ than the M-320’s, and I still got to play with a buckle which kept the little Dutch boy in me happy. Every used mattress has a shit stain somewhere, and these shoes were no exception to that rule. These shoes sported three, yes three, toe spikes. I removed the stupid metal inserts and just sucked it up. In no time the front of the shoe was trashed (in Shimano’s defense they suggested that you either run the spikes or the inserts).
A great pair of shoes gone to the bad because somewhere out there someone thinks toe spikes are a good idea on mountain bike shoes. Who’s using these damn things? Confess you bastards!!!!! Why can’t somebody make my dream shoe????
What’s my dream shoe??
Rubber outter sole with NO TOE SPIKES
Non-carbon mid-sole (carbon soles are too stiff for hike-a-bike, which happens to be a big part of SS’ing)
Two velcro straps and one clicky buckle strap (cause buckles look so Robocop)
A tongue that stays in one place
No more than three colors (I’m counting black as a color here)
A really cool name like “M-something numerical and three digits long”
That could only happen in my dreams, right???
Wrong.
Introducing the creatively named M-085.

This shoe is the brain child of someone at Nashbar (yes, a mail order demon of the second level) and the folks at Shimano.
Here’s the description:
“If you’re a serious about the trail, then you know you need a shoe with an uncompromising fit that’s stable, resilient and offers a solid pedaling platform. The MO85 is a high-level, off-road performer designed for all types of cyclists at a price that wont break the bank. 1 Ratchet and 2 offset Velcro straps secure your foot. SPD compatible.”
Let’s see, does it meet my criterias? Without scrolling back up to look up at them I would have to say yes. Who cares? The marketing on this shoe plays dead-on to the consumer in me, so much so that I ordered two pair sight unseen. I’m “Serious about the trail”, and I could use all the stability and resilience I can get. It’s like someone crawled in my ear, looked at the shoe lobe in my brain, took a picture with one of those mini spy cameras, took the microfilm back to Nashbar headquarters, phoned up Yozo
Shimano, and said “We must make great shoe for Dicky, and perhaps he will put us on his blog”.
“What size does he wear” asked Yozo.
”Dunno” replied the miniature Shimano spy, “Better make some 43’s and a few 44’s to be on the safe side”.
That’s right, they only have 43’s and 44’s in stock, so they musta been thinking about me when they went into production on these bad boys.*
So what do I think of the shoes? I’ve had two rides in them so far, and I can honestly say they do what shoes should do. The soles are entirely rubber, and the instep portion is wide enough to keep a decent footing on a slippery rock. Not getting clipped in right away on a nasty technical section doesn’t necessarily mean certain death when you’ve got a little rubber on the pedal (try that with your exposed carbon soled shoe). The lugs do look “enthusiast level”, but who sees the bottom of your shoe anyways?

Would I recommend them? Does this answer your question?

Ahhhhh…. the Team Dicky Seal of Semi-Approval. Why only Semi-Approval?

The toe box area is squared off like a pair of boots. Most racing shoes are pointed at the end like a pair of fashionable lady shoes, and there’s a good reason for it. Pointed shoes are faster. If I just focus on riding I don’t notice it so much, but if I catch the shoe in my peripheral I start to slow down. I can’t help it. For one to be fast one must look fast, and these shoes look half-fast.
We’ll see how they do on a longer ride in the next month or so.
*Late edit: Nashbar is now showing zero shoes in stock. Wow, I can sell porn to the Pope, and even he knows you can get that shit for free. Now I see these shoes are also in stock (in most sizes) over in merry old England.